In a recent video from the YouTube series, “The Secret Sauce with Grossy Pelosi,” blogger and food enthusiast Dan Pelosi joins Marian Bull to bake her grandmother’s tomato soup spice cake, which many 20th century home cooks made as an economical treat when fresh ingredients were hard to come by. The procedure is pretty familiar: They mix the dry ingredients and beat in some eggs, but then they add a can of Campbell’s tomato soup in place of another wet ingredient, such as milk. Presumably, the soup doesn’t just add moisture to the cake, but also sweetness and body due to its added sugars and wheat flour (via Campbell’s). After covering the cake with a cream cheese frosting, the duo samples the thoroughly spiced cake that doesn’t outright taste like tomatoes. It’s so light that Pelosi mentions he could have it for breakfast.
Typical tomato recipes are usually for salads, pasta dishes, or dips, like pico de gallo. However, the fruit is mostly made of water — around 95% — and its carb component means it’s sweet as well as acidic. Therefore, it’s the perfect ingredient to add moisture and unexpected flavor to a dessert like cake, says Bon Appétit. Other sweets with tomatoes are more refreshing for summer, such as an Ecuadorian sorbet made with tree tomatoes. If you’re a fan of the fruit, go ahead and add tomatoes or tomato soup to your next homemade treat. It may surprise you how much you enjoy it!